〔REVIEW ON BOOK
AND EDUCATION書刊與教育的評論〕
The Comparison of
the Academic Degrees of Traditional Chinese Medical Colleges of China with
Similar Education in the United States
中國的中醫學院中醫專業畢業生與美國的中醫學院畢業生專業水準的比較
By Kexin Bao, Ph.D., L.Ac.
美國 包克新
In view of the
following five points, it was concluded that traditional Chinese medical
graduates from traditional Chinese medical (TCM, same as below) colleges or
universities in China have higher or equivalent education levels as doctors of
traditional oriental medicine (TOM) in the United States of America.
Usually, a medical
bachelor degree will be conferred to most of the schools that institute five to
six-year-schooling (a few schools have four year programs) in China. If a graduate
continues to study for additional three to six years, a medical master or
medical doctor degree can be conferred in China.
1. It is noted from
the table below that two years of college education is required for admission
to TOM colleges in the United States. However, the total school hours required
in the USA are significantly less than that required in China. A full-time
study is required in China, while the study-hour totals about forty-two weeks
per year, six or five days a week, and six hours a day.
2. The traditional
Chinese medical colleges in
3. The TCM colleges in
4. The TCM colleges in
China have been recognized as regular medical colleges by the U.S. government.
The graduates from these colleges are eligible to take the U.S. medical
licensure examination like the graduates from regular medical schools in the
U.S. Once the examinees obtain medical license, they may be given the title of
M.D. In contrast, the graduates from TCM colleges in the U.S. are currently not
eligible to participate in the U.S. medical licensure examination.
5. In the USA, people
with bachelor degree who study for couple more years in non-medical schools can
only obtain a second bachelor’s degree if their
major is different from the previous major. However, people who have previous
non-medical schooling can be conferred a TCM master by the TCM colleges if they
have studied for three years. In fact, such TCM degree may be equal to the level of the second-degree conferred by
non-medical schools mentioned above. This kind of TCM degree may be considered
as a second degree, and its academic level in medicine is lower than the
medical bachelor degree of
It is clear that the
academic level of medical bachelor degree conferred by TCM schools in China is
higher than those TCM master degrees conferred by the TCM schools in the United
States. In addition, the TCM education system in Taiwan is similar to the TCM
education system in mainland China mentioned above.
基於以下五點理由,可以認為中國的中醫學院中醫專業畢業生的專業水準高於或至少等於美國的中醫學院博士畢業生的專業水準(中國的中醫學院中醫專業大多數為五年制或六年制,極少數為四年制,授與醫學學士學位,如再繼續修業三至六年,可獲碩士或博士學位):
一、從下表可知,雖然美國的中醫學教育招生時要求入學者具有二年或以上的學院(或大學)教育學歷,但進入中醫學院後實際所學專業知識少於中國的中醫學院的學生所學。(中國的大學是全日制教學,除去節假日外,全年約四十二週,每週學習六天,近年因實行五天工作制而改為每週學習五天,每天約六學時,故表中有每週五天制與每週六天制兩種情形。)
二、中國的中醫大學被世界衛生組織列入了世界醫學院名冊,而美國的中醫學院還沒有列入。
三、中國的中醫大學被中國政府認可為正規的醫學教育,而美國的中醫大學還沒被美國政府承認為正規的醫學教育,僅為私立的第二級職業訓練學校。
四、中國的中醫大學也被美國政府認可為正規的醫學教育,因中國的中醫大學畢業生可參加美國的醫師執照考試,取得執照後可用的頭銜與美國的西醫師所用的頭銜相同,亦即其專業水準(醫學博士)相同。而美國的中醫大學的畢業生則不可以參加美國的醫師執照考試。
五、在美國,在取得學士或碩士學位後進入非醫學專業學院再學習四年,如果所學專業與原專業不同,並不可以取得博士學位,而中醫學院盡管學生入學前並不是醫學或中醫學專業,兼職學習三∼四年也可得碩士學位,故這個中醫學碩士實際上相當於其他非醫學專業的第二學士學位,也即美國當前的某些中醫學碩士在學術上相當於中國的醫學學士或更低。
可見,中國的中醫大學學士畢業生的專業水準高於美國的中醫大學碩士畢業生。
同時須指出,台灣的中醫教育與中國大陸的中醫教育有類同的情況。
The Comparison of
the Academic Degrees of Traditional Chinese Medical
Colleges of
Degrees Items |
TCM (TOM) Colleges of |
TCM Colleges of |
|||||||||||||||||
Master Degree |
Doctoral Degree |
Five Years Bachelor |
Six Years Bachelor |
Seven Years Master |
Eight ~ Nine Years Master |
Ten ~ Twelve Years Doctor |
|||||||||||||
Previous Schooling Required |
Two Years
College Level after High School(1200 Non -medicine hours) |
Two Years
College Level after High School or higher?(1200 Non-medicine hours or more) |
Taking National
Admission Examination & Excellent Candidate Selected after High School |
Taking National
Admission Examination & Excellent Candidate Selected after High School |
Taking National
Admission Examination & Excellent Candidate Selected after High School |
Taking National
Admission Examination & Excellent Candidate Selected with Bachelor Degree
Usually |
Taking National
Admission Examination & Excellent Candidate Selected with Master Degree
Usually |
||||||||||||
Schooling Hours |
2700 |
4000 |
42Weeks/Year 6 Days/Week 6 Hours/Day Total: 7560 |
42Weeks/Year 5 Days/Week 6 Hours/Day Total: 6300 |
42Weeks/Year 6 Days/Week 6 Hours/Day Total: 9072 |
42Weeks/Year 5 Days/Week 6 Hours/Day Total: 7560 |
42Weeks/Year 6 Days/Week 6 Hours/Day Total:10584 |
42Weeks/Year 5 Days/Week 6 Hours/Day Total: 8820 |
42Weeks/Year 6 Days/Week 6 Hours/Day Total:12096~ 13608 |
42Weeks/Year 5 Days/Week 6 Hours/Day Total:10080~ 11340 |
42Weeks/Year 6 Days/Week 6 Hours/Day Total:15120~ 18144 |
42Weeks/Year 5 Days/Week 6 Hours/Day Total:12600~ 15120 |
|||||||
Schooling Period |
3~4 Years of
Part Time |
4~? Years of
Part Time |
5 Years of Full
Time |
6 Years of Full
Time |
7 Years of Full
Time |
8~9 Years of
Full Time |
10~12 Years of
Full Time |
||||||||||||
Approved Regular Medical Education by
Government or Not |
No, It is |
No, It is |
Yes, It is
equal to |
Yes, It is
equal to |
Yes, It is
equal to |
Yes, It is
equal to |
Yes, It is
equal to |
||||||||||||
Graduate is Qualified to Become Medical Doctor
or Not |
No,
Acupuncturist only |
No,
Acupuncturist only or higher |
Yes, Graduate
is Qualified to Become Medical Doctor |
Yes, Graduate
is Qualified to Become Medical Doctor |
Yes, Graduate
is Qualified to Become Medical Doctor |
Yes, Graduate
is Qualified to Become Medical Doctor |
Yes, Graduate
is Qualified to Become Medical Doctor |
||||||||||||
It is Listed into WHO's World Directory of
Med. Schools or Not |
No |
No |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
||||||||||||
Graduate is Qualified to Take U.S. '
Acupuncturist Licensure Examination or Not |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
||||||||||||
Title can be Used for Licensed Acupuncture
Practitioner |
Acupuncturist |
Acupuncturist,
or Plus DOM, Will be Discussed |
Acupuncturist,
or Plus DOM, is a
Contentious Point |
Acupuncturist,
or Plus DOM, is a
Contentious Point |
Acupuncturist,
or Plus DOM, is a
Contentious Point |
Acupuncturist,
or Plus DOM, is a
Contentious Point |
Acupuncturist,
or Plus DOM, is a
Contentious Point |
||||||||||||
Qualified to Take |
No |
No |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
||||||||||||
Title Can be Used for Licensed Medical
Practitioner |
No |
No |
MD |
MD |
MD |
MD |
MD |
||||||||||||
中國與美國的中醫學院畢業生學力比較表
班別 項目 |
美國的中醫大學 |
中國的中醫大學(台灣的中醫教育與中國大陸的中醫教育相似) |
|||||||||||||||||
碩士班 |
博士班 |
五年制學士班 |
六年制學士班 |
七年制碩士班 |
八∼九年制碩士班 |
十∼十二年制博士班 |
|||||||||||||
入學前要 求的學歷 |
高中畢業後 再有二年制 學院水平 (1200學時 非醫學課程) |
高中畢業後再 有二年制學院 水平或更高?(1200學時 非醫學課程或多) |
高中畢業後經全國統一考試後擇優錄取 |
高中畢業後經全國統一考試後擇優錄取 |
高中畢業後經全國統一考試後擇優錄取 |
通常在取得學士學位後經統一考試後擇優錄取 |
通常在取得碩士學位後經統一考試後擇優錄取 |
||||||||||||
修業學時 |
2700 |
4000 |
以42週/年 6天/週 6學時/天計 共7560 |
以42週/年 5天/週 6學時/天計 共6300 |
以42週/年 6天/週 6學時/天計 共9072 |
以42週/年 5天/週 6學時/天計 共7560 |
以42週/年 6天/週 6學時/天計 共10584 |
以42週/年 5天/週 6學時/天計 共8820 |
以42週/年 6天/週 6學時/天計 共12096~ 13608 |
以42週/年 5天/週 6學時/天計 共10080~ 11340 |
以42週/年 6天/週 6學時/天計 共15120~ 18144 |
以42週/年 5天/週 6學時/天計 共12600~ 15120 |
|||||||
修業年限 |
兼職三∼四年 |
兼職四∼?年 |
全職五年 |
全職六年 |
全職七年 |
全職八∼九年 |
全職十∼十二年 |
||||||||||||
是否為國家 認可的正規 醫學教育 |
否,僅為私立的第 二級職業學校 |
否,僅為私立 的第二級職業學 校或可升級? |
是,與西醫院校同等, 均為正規醫學教育 |
是,與西醫院校同等, 均為正規醫學教育 |
是,與西醫院校同等, 均為正規醫學教育 |
是,與西醫院校同等, 均為正規醫學教育 |
是,與西醫院校同等, 均為正規醫學教育 |
||||||||||||
畢業後是否 可成為政府 認可的醫師 |
否,僅為針灸技師或針灸師 |
否,僅為針灸技 師或針灸師,或 可稱中醫師? |
是,可成為中國 政府認可的醫師 |
是,可成為中國 政府認可的醫師 |
是,可成為中國 政府認可的醫師 |
是,可成為中國 政府認可的醫師 |
是,可成為中國 政府認可的醫師 |
||||||||||||
是否列入了 世界衛生組 認可的醫學 院的名單 |
否 |
否 |
是 |
是 |
是 |
是 |
是 |
||||||||||||
是否可考美國的中醫師執照 |
是 |
是 |
是 |
是 |
是 |
是 |
是 |
||||||||||||
取得美國的 中醫師執照 後可用何頭銜 |
針灸技師(或針灸師) |
針灸技師(或針 灸師),或加針灸博士頭銜待研討 |
針灸技師(或針灸師),是否可加針灸博士頭銜是爭議點 |
針灸技師(或針灸師),是否可加針灸博士頭銜是爭議點 |
針灸技師(或針灸師),是否可加針灸博士頭銜是爭議點 |
針灸技師(或針灸師),是否可加針灸博士頭銜是爭議點 |
針灸技師(或針灸師),是否可加針灸博士頭銜是爭議點 |
||||||||||||
是否可考美國的醫師執照 |
否 |
否 |
是 |
是 |
是 |
是 |
是 |
||||||||||||
取得美國醫 師執照後可 用何頭銜 |
否 |
否 |
醫師或醫學博士(MD)頭銜 |
醫師或醫學博士(MD)頭銜 |
醫師或醫學博士(MD)頭銜 |
醫師或醫學博士(MD)頭銜 |
醫師或醫學博士(MD)頭銜 |
||||||||||||
洽詢地址Add.: 2712 San Gabriel
Boulevard
Rosemead, CA 91770 U.S.A.
電話Tel.: (626) 288-1199
傳真Fax: (626) 288-4199